Inscrutable, five stars: 2025 reading notes
These are the books I read in 2025—

10:04 by Ben Lerner — Relatively early Lerner, and one of the last of his I’ve gotten to. I told the gc it was “poppin.” Later I sent them a picture of a page about potential material for a university library archive, which a character says is limited to “massive and obsessive electronic correspondence with my best writer friends that’s poorly written and full of gossip and shit-talking and divulges all manner of embarrassing information.” Troy said, “Yup, that’s us lol.” I kept pestering Zac to read Lerner, and he eventually submitted and started listening to (and criticizing) the Transcription audiobook, which I told him was “labgrown Crow ragebait.”

There’s Always This Year by Hanif Abdurraqib — A gift from my wife. I’ve become a basketball guy in the last few years, so it was fun to read an emotional, intellectual, cultural, poetic, memoiristic, book-length whatever about, largely, LeBron James, but also obviously other stuff too.

Log Off by Kristen Felicetti — I don’t want to just say I can’t remember much about many of these books, but it was more than a year ago, maybe cut me some slack? This one was of particular interest because early online correspondence plays into several story ideas I’ve been letting simmer for, uh, more than a decade. Still not convinced I can do them. Ironic, given how much of life continues to happen online.

Milk and Why I Am Sad by Dorothea Lasky — Reading the Lasky books, I kept thinking about hearing her read from the “Do you want to dip the rat / Completely in oil / Do you want to dip the rat / Before we eat it eat it” poem at Bennington years ago. The audience was rolling. Really fun to reencounter that one in text.
Flat Earth by Anika Jade Levy — Reading this is not unlike giving yourself microscopic cuts by stubbornly continuing to swipe at a shattered touchscreen (complimentary).
Do Hard Things by Steve Magness — A bit of a letdown. More recently I’ve been watching Magness’s videos about running training philosophies, and he’s a smart dude, but the book felt generic. Like, the title said everything there was to say haha.

The Living god and Proximity by Sam Heaps — My good friend Graham got engaged to Sam, so I had to brush up on their oeuvre, and I’m so glad to’ve been introduced. Dark, sticky, scary honesty. Heavy and beautiful stuff. I told the group chat (including Sam’s now-husband) that Proximity has a “you will look me in the eyes while I say this” feeling to it.

Earth Angel by Madeline Cash — I started reading this when it came out two years earlier, lost it, and only found it again in November 2025. Favorite part: she ends a story with a semi-non-sequitur line about the meth head roommate/boyfriend(?) character making waffles “without eggs or flour or milk or water.” I was kind of stunned at how good of a story ending it was.
Female Loneliness Epidemic and Baby Bruise by Danielle Chelosky — As a Cheloskiite, I dutifully preordered both, as I will continue to do for future releases, may there be many, and then felt a bit silly learning she’d sent them to my gc pals for free. But I stand by my purchases. To mix some metaphors, it’s great to watch her keep digging and dissecting the endless font.
Tropisms by Nathalie Sarraute — Landed on this one probably due to some praise from Calvin Westra? Don’t remember much about it other than that it was good.
Out of the Blank by Elaine Equi — Following my habit of reading anything I see Andrew Weatherhead recommend. I told the gc it was a “weird sex thing.” ?
After Eden (draft) by Sebastian Castillo — Just you guys wait. Just you friggin wait.
T Singer, Shyness and Dignity, and Novel 11, Book 18 by Dag Solstad — Said to the gc: “solstad and fosse are interesting bc the voice can sometimes trick you into thinking theyre about to try telling a joke. but they never do.”
banger book by Zac Smith — What if someone wrote a book and it was all bangers? Agents, editors, and publishers—contact Zac to find out.
moth girl by Calvin Westra — moth girl is disarmingly funny and fulla heart. I really admire Calvin’s ambition with this. He pulled off a delightfully strange, breezy, and yet highly-wrought gem. Inspiring stuff.
Mischief by Hal Hartley — Got it as a Kickstarter perk for his latest film, which I also now have on Blu-ray but still (in 2026) haven’t watched. Hartley is one of my two favorite directors. Poems were fine!

Take It Personally by Claire Hopple — Spying on a local diarist, a psychic roommate, a missing nudist neighbor? I’m really into this almost slapstick, zany bent she’s been on in her recent work.
The Other Light by Troy James Weaver — I’m so amped on this one. It’s got me all amped. When it comes out it might have an entirely different title? Whatever, look out for it! Buy all the Troys!
Actual Air by David Berman — I’d been holding out for a physical copy, got impatient, and ebooked it. It’s def him! Silver Jews guy! Genius/charming/cutting/poignant/devastating!

Foreclosure Gothic by Harris Lahti — Man, that death scene. Sheesh. What a ride. I did think it’d be more about painting houses, though. Not enough ladder talk.
A Prank of Georges by Thalia Field and Abigail Lang — Thalia was a teacher of mine and I’m really fond of her. Inscrutable, five stars.
Muscle Man by Jordan Castro — Good, reads quickly. Got my brain moving. An interesting container for ideas. I liked the way it expanded upon and progressed past the preoccupations of The Novelist.
New Seeds of Contemplation by Thomas Merton — I texted: “listening to this thomas merton audiobook on dog walks lately, it’s pretty fire, about ‘the contemplative life,'” and “there are nuggets that hit so hard and I keep wondering how they’d translate for someone without a current or former god relationship or curiosity.” Two of the illustrative nuggets I sent along: “A clever kind of insolent servility, a peculiar combination of ambition, stubbornness and flexibility, a ‘third ear’ keenly attuned to the subtlest modulations of the fashionable cliché—with all this you can pass as a saint or a genius if you conform to the right group. … They dig you. You are canonized. You are the embodiment of their own complacency.” And: “If a writer is so cautious that he never writes anything that cannot be criticized, he will never write anything that can be read. If you want to help other people you have got to make up your mind to write things that some men will condemn.”

American Lit by Jennifer Greidus — I loved working with Jenn at XRAY. She rules and I want so much success for her. Grateful she sent me a copy. Reporting to the gc I said, “I guess I dont know what erotica is literaturewise, but this certainly feels like it.” Also: “It’s like… The CW does Dennis Cooper, starring filipthoughts.” And: “I mean there’s a lot of cocks, you might like that about it.”
Jesus: A Pilgrimage by James Martin — Inspired by seeing the Franciscan ordination of my old friend Father Lawrence, staying at the friary in the Bronx, and getting a short glimpse of that life. I wanted to understand Catholicism from a slightly accessible angle (Martin has been relatively hip on LGBTQ stuff…). Learned some stuff about Jesus!

Another Roadside Attraction by Tom Robbins — It’d been a while since I’d read Robbins, who I’ve enjoyed in the past. His death prompted it, and I wanted something whimsical and fun. Kinda sluggish to get through! Some goofy but fun bits in it tho. Claire’s Take It Personally gave me much more of the energy I’d been hoping to find here.
Lenz by Georg Büchner — Listened to it on audio because brother Troy sent the YouTube link. Loved it atmospherically, don’t remember many details! Should read it in print.
A Little Daylight Left by Sarah Kay — Sarah Kay, I gotta say, writes bops!
Discipline Equals Freedom by Jocko Willink — Wife and son left for spring break and I put on this book by an ex-SEAL and started smashing tiles in my bathroom. The bathroom was leaking. Felt very cathartic and masculine.
Bjarki, Not Bjarki by Matthew J. C. Clark — A loaner from my friend Brian, a signed copy given to him by his wife. Fun read, felt nice and local. Odd undercurrent of relationship discord that never quite comes to the surface, which was somewhat unsatisfying. But it’s fine. Hard wood!
Woebegone by Claire Donato — I love cats! I love my cat and Claire’s cats, at least.
Kudos by Rachel Cusk — Dragged a bit more than the first 2 in the trilogy but like Seb says…
jesus christ, the last scene in kudos https://t.co/l88vJlGcLn
— sebastian castillo (@bartlebytaco) April 19, 2019

All My Cats by Bohumil Hrabal — More cats! Hrabal is phenomenal. His Too Loud a Solitude was one of my late stepdad’s favorites, so reading another one was like hanging out with him again in a way.
Fresh, Green Life and The Zoo of Thinking by Sebastian Castillo — I wrote up Fresh, Green Life for BOMB (an Editor’s Choice!). Here’s how I closed it: “Fresh, Green Life is about having a mind that believes it can juke the messiness of being human, of thinking yourself smarter than your circumstances, and realizing that having an intellect isn’t the same as having a life.” In the review I also mention the clipped whimsy of The Zoo of Thinking, which includes the story “The Cigarette Painter,” first published in BOMB. As I put it there, his work is “only growing in its playfulness, generosity, and gravity.”

The Champ is Here by Nathan Dragon — When Lamb asked me about it on IG, I told him “I appreciated that it felt like a kind of autofiction scrapbook selfportrait … I loved the quiet.” Dragon’s on insta-read status for me.

And the rest! As with last time, omission is not necessarily (though might be) a reflection of their worthiness. Comment or DM if you want me to summon a thought on any of the following (your own book being fair game!): Jesus Freak by Cletus Crow, Living Buddha, Living Christ by Thich Nhat Hanh, Phallic Symbols by Cletus Crow, The Anxious Generation by Jonathan Haidt, Rerun Era by Joanna Howard, The Coin by Yasmin Zaher, Far From the Tree by Andrew Solomon, Disintegration Made Plain and Easy by Kiik Araki-Kawaguchi, The End IV: Parents & Children, Sprinter Runs the Marathon by Dave Morrison, UnWorld by Jayson Greene, Opioid, Indiana by Brian Allen Carr.
